When Progress Just Isn't Enough

When Progress Just Isn't Enough
12/7/2011 7:14:48 AM

Texas had made progress in recent years in how we protect and care for kids in our state systems. Unfortunately, there is still a lot of work to be done, as some disturbing news stories of late suggest.

Perhaps the most tragic of recent developments involve allegations of sexual abuse of an underage patient by a psychiatrist in a state mental hospital. Heartbreaking in and of itself, this seems all the more tragic because it could have been avoided. While the state made improvements in recent years in how it protects children and youth in state supported living centers and juvenile justice facilities from abuse and exploitation, similar improvements weren’t made within the states’ mental hospital system. If they were, the young patient may have been spared this tragedy. Need I mention that the changes in both the state supported living centers, which care for individuals with disabilities, and the juvenile justice system were made only after incidents of abuse or exploitation had occurred within their own facilities? We shouldn’t need a crisis to occur before we do things we know we should.Creative Commons License photo credit: Newbirth35

Also concerning is a recently released federal report on the practice of prescribing psychotropic medication to kids in foster care. These include anti-depressants, anti-anxiety medication, and treatment for ADHD or insomnia. It’s not surprising to learn that kids who have experienced trauma or neglect would be prescribed these types of medications more than kids who haven’t been placed in foster care or that kids with mental health concerns are overrepresented in the foster care system. But it did surprise me to learn that kids in the Texas foster care system are prescribed these medications at higher rates than kids in the foster care systems of other states examined in the study. Why was I surprised? Because in 2005, Texas put in place some good policies to address high rates of prescribing psychotropic medications in the foster care system, and since then the percentage of children in the system receiving psychotropic medications has gone down–which is great news. But the recent national comparison reminds us that even when progress is made, when it comes to our kids, we can’t accept "better” as "good enough.”

Beyond simply making progress, we as a state still need to do a better job–a better job of being proactive in our choices to do what’s right and a better job of making sure our kids get the treatment they need, not just a treatment that may be the most expedient.

Doing a better job isn’t just about improved surveillance, stricter regulations, and heightened oversight, although those are undoubtedly needed. It’s also about the Legislature putting its money where its mouth is. It’s about providing funding to support its new law that promotes trauma-informed care within the foster care system, a good step in making sure those who work with abuse victims understand how trauma can impact victims and learn effective ways to respond to them. It’s about paying a rate that attracts and keeps good doctors and psychiatrists to treat our vulnerable youth. It’s about restoring the drastic cuts the Legislature made to child abuse prevention and intervention programs. It’s about making more community-based mental health services available to families, so that more kids can stay safely in their homes while they get the treatment and services they need to be successful at home and in school.

It’s about taking seriously the idea that we have the power to make decisions that can set a child on a course to reach his or her full potential. In fact, we as a state hold all the power to determine whether the needs of certain vulnerable children in our system get met. It’s an awesome responsibility with an awesome potential payoff, and it requires staying focused not merely on making progress but on making Texas proud.

1 Comments
12/8/2011 12:08:50 PM
This is a very troublesome issue and unfortunately these vulnerable children weren't taken seriously because they were in an institution that was supposed to be taking care of them, their caretaker was the abuser, and it is only natural that the victims would be doubted:
1. sometimes individuals in such institutions will lie to get out of their situation, say anything to go home or out of institution.
2. sometimes the conditions individuals in such institutions are there for include chronic pathological lying and manipulation.
3. drugs administered to individuals in such institutions sometimes cause distortion of reality
4. family members and friends often don't believe victims, I know we don't like to believe this but it is true.
5. individuals in these institutions experience an unfair prejudice for very fact they are in these types of settings and therefore are deemed not "credible". Children, in general, are tough witnesses in any case, but with this stereotype and our justice system; the accused is the one that the system protects not the victims.

I have faith in HHS and CPS that this will be handled accordingly because of the awareness that is being spread by people like you and advocates all over. This includes, me, I have a big mouth and so do a lot of other people, but also understand we need to support HHS and CPS in their actions; they fired the Doctor and now Texas needs to make sure we ask ourselves what can we do to assist in making sure this doesn't happen again? Not only this doctor not practicing but how can we serve our community to help? It is the courts that will end up messing this case up from here on out, not these two agencies...my hearts will go out to them because they will be blamed and I can only imagine how frustrating it gets...I do know this: people who work at these two agencies certainly don't do it for the money, they really do believe in the cause. Are there exceptions? Sure but on a whole, they are dedicated but are constantly facing barriers and policies that stall them from doing things that sometimes could prevent some tragic abuse situations. This never gets reported though, it is always their fault and I find this sad, not saying it is never their fault but when I have actually taken time to trace back cases....it is typically the courts or policies....which are not always bad either - they were put in place to protect the people. The problem is, no one thing fits each situation.

I honestly don't know the answer to the situation, but this is what I do know; I volunteer and ask what can I do to help? What is broken right now that needs immediate fixing, might know a source that will donate some time...might not...can't hurt to ask. If we all did this, because we all have unique specialties, our communities on a whole will be much better off, we cannot depend on the Government to fix the problems, they are stalled because the Federal Government cannot even "play in the same sandbox" together....so we can do what we can, no more of these super committee meetings the state does, take a year to overhaul the system....we don't have the money people. Implementation too costly and we as private sector people know this and don't let this go on in our companies do we? If you don't have the funds you don't do it, you work with what you have and that is it. Company's don't run in the red, they run in black - we are talking private companies.

Believe me the system is really broken, do you know there are no services for people if your child isn't a CPS child and you aren't on state aid? If you are lucky, your child will get coverage for a few weeks but then you are out of luck. Where is the justice in this? Oh, mental hospitals for people in Texas that have insurance? Good luck and again these children are just as vulnerable....yes victims of sexual abuse, but parents may have adopted them or whatever but you have insurance...nobody is addressing this issue at all. These children are just as vulnerable if not more because there is no place for them to get help because insurance won't cover them and no parents cannot afford the programs.

Last, thank you for addressing the issue of the drugs being administered to children for wrong treatments. This is not just to our state aided kids in institutions, it is a widely used practice where there are lawsuits spanning back to 1996 to 2006 against makers of Risperdal® for deceptive marketing practices and not having FDA approval for use in children Under 18, then children under 13 and never for certain conditions. They continue to market this drug, despite its alarming side effects and nobody is doing anything about it. Sure there are reports on it but guess what, it is still being prescribed and unless you are in habit of running research on drugs that are prescribed to your children....you could be put in really bad position. When your child is in one of these institutions, you need to ask or inquire what drug, why and understand you are parent and can tell them to remove your child from any drug you don't feel comfortable with. Just like in the case with everyone assuming the Dr. was God in the abuse case, same thought process happens with advice of Doctors who prescribe medication, they see so may patients and have relationships with drug companies....investigate on your own. No drug will have zero issues, but in the case of Risperdal ® , this was the most blatant case of misuse of marketing and prescribing I have seen....side effects are really bad and long term we will have to wait and see.

I am sorry for this long-winded response but I am an advocate who is passionate on child abuse prevention, protecting children and spreading awareness and education. I have nothing to gain, I want to see a better world and want my community to be a better place. I understand the long term effects child abuse has on communities, there is a saying out there that is true: Pay Now or Pay Later....if we continue to do nothing, look the other way and pretend it doesn't happen we will be dealing with it for decades to come because the victims will grow up to be angry, possibly violent, repeat offenders and this is a real cost to our society and then the cycle will just repeat itself. how many people in jail, prison or mental institutions are not victims of child abuse? The number is very low? Now don't mistake this for all people who are abused will have this outcome, but there is a definite correlation so why wouldn't you invest in a child's future to possibly turn around so they can be productive participants of society; whether you donate your time or money....do something.

Submit a Comment
Name
E-mail
Web Site  (optional)
Comment
HTML tags are not allowed.

 

© Copyright 2012, Texans Care for Children. All rights reserved.